Inside the Umbrella Sector: Challenges, Changes, and What’s Next in 2025 and Beyond

Inside the Umbrella Sector: Challenges, Changes, and What’s Next in 2025 and Beyond

Umbrella companies are an integral part of the UK’s labour market, bridging the gap between contractors and businesses in a post-IR35 world. Yet, beneath the surface of this seemingly straightforward solution lies an industry riddled with challenges, from tax avoidance schemes to regulatory gaps that threaten both contractors and the broader labour market. Here, Qdos SEO Seb Maley takes a closer look at the evolution, complexities, and future of the umbrella sector.

What are umbrella companies, and why do they exist?

In a nutshell, umbrella companies are intermediaries that employ contractors, handling all the administrative tasks such as tax deductions, National Insurance contributions, and paying HMRC. They operate under the PAYE system, meaning the contractor is treated as an employee of the umbrella company.

Umbrella companies became a fixture in contracting after IR35 rules were originally introduced in April 2000, designed to catch contractors working through limited companies who had an ’employment relationship’ with their clients yet failed to pay the correct amount in PAYE taxes. Umbrella companies provided a solution by allowing contractors to work flexibly while ensuring that tax obligations were met.

The rules were revamped in 2017 and 2021 for the public and private sectors respectively, making clients responsible for assessing IR35 status in most instances. Not wanting to be caught out by the changes, many chose to avoid engaging contractors through limited companies altogether, with umbrella companies offering a way to continue engaging contractors without the associated tax risks.

As a result, the umbrella sector is now a massive industry, with an estimated 700,000 users and some of the larger firms boasting annual turnovers in the billions.

It never rains, but it pours: challenges in the umbrella market

It's important to acknowledge that umbrella companies play a key role in the UK’s flexible labour market. For many hirers, engaging self-employed workers isn’t always practical, nor is hiring full-time employees. Umbrella companies offer a flexible middle ground for both parties. That said, the umbrella market faces significant challenges that threaten its stability and reputation.

IR35 fallout: contractors’ frustrations

Many long-time contractors were told to either leave or sign up with an umbrella company, as organisations became wary of engaging personal service companies. Unsurprisingly, this left a bitter taste for many in the contracting world. For many, it wasn’t just about taxes, it was about losing control over their own business model and career.

The problem of non-compliant umbrellas

One of the major issues in the umbrella company industry isn’t with legitimate umbrellas, but with companies posing as umbrellas while actually running tax avoidance schemes. For over two decades, the contracting world has been plagued by these schemes, which exploit the contracting model to avoid or evade tax. While these structures may seem like ways to reduce an individual’s tax bill, in reality, they often serve the interests of unscrupulous operators who make large profits at the contractor’s expense.

Many contractors were unknowingly drawn into these schemes, not to evade tax but simply to avoid the risks of IR35 and find a simple way to offer their services. These schemes weren’t limited to high-paid consultants but have also been widespread in sectors like the NHS and construction. Unfortunately, it’s often the contractors who get targeted by HMRC, leading to highly controversial measures like the loan charge, which has caused financial ruin and immense stress for thousands.

Umbrella regulation: What’s happening now, and what’s on the horizon?

This all points to a deeper issue: the umbrella company and employment intermediary sector remains largely unregulated. HMRC’s own data shows that £500 million was lost to disguised remuneration tax avoidance schemes in 2022 to 2023, almost all of which was facilitated by non-compliant umbrella companies. Given the sheer volume of money and taxpayers involved, this lack of oversight clearly seems unsustainable.

Despite HMRC’s efforts to crack down on tax avoidance schemes and their users, these schemes continue to thrive. In fact, HMRC regularly updates a list of known avoidance schemes, adding more companies every few weeks, speaking to the scale of the issue.

These challenges have pushed the new Labour government to act, setting out measures within the 2024 Autumn budget. From April 2026, recruitment agencies will be responsible for accounting for PAYE on payments made to the workers supplied via umbrella companies. If there’s no agency involved, this responsibility will fall on the end client’s business instead. While this isn't true regulation, the goal is to push the industry to self-regulate. By shifting liability to the recruitment firm, the theory is that due diligence should be dramatically improved and the shady operators weeded out.

However, the concerns remain: Will this shift lead to a repeat of the IR35 situation, where businesses, faced with liability, become overly cautious or even refuse to engage contractors altogether? If this happens, the very flexibility that umbrella companies offer could be further compromised. The risk is that the pendulum swings too far, and in trying to tackle one problem, we create new challenges. Without careful implementation, these changes could have unintended consequences that ultimately hurt contractors the most.

To stay informed on what lies ahead, subscribe to our YouTube channel and newsletter for exclusive updates and expert analysis on the evolving umbrella company landscape.